Posted by: jpmeyer | January 6, 2009

first impressions: sora wo kakeru shoujo

I believe that I read that Sora wo Kakeru Shoujo is supposed to be a “spiritual successor” to the My-Hime series.  When I think of “spiritual successors”, my first thought is usually how Fallout is a spiritual successor to Wasteland.  There’s no continuity between the two, but some kind of similarity in theme or setting to make them “feel” similar even though they’re on different planes.

(so like, are we supposed to call it "sora kake girl" or something?)

(so like, are we supposed to call it "sora kake girl" or something?)

Sora wo Kakeru Shoujo has some staff in common.  A lot of the voice cast is the same, and both series have the same character designer director.  The most important difference is that the writers are different, which is one of the biggest factors in TV production.  Tone and themes are a little bit more of a stretch until you dig down a little more.

For example, the settings are different.  The My-Hime shows took place at schools (although one was a Japanese high school while the other was medieval-ish maid-ish school), while Sora wo Kakeru Shoujo is well, all over the place.  Yet while the settings are different, both shows are playing with magical girl conventions (with Sorakake being a more Nanoha-ish sci-fi tack.)  Tone is probably the closest analog.  Sorakake is much more madcap than even the goofiest parts of My-Otome Zwei, but regardless both series have a playful, irreverent tone to them.

The tone is kind of hard to really accurately describe, though.  I’m reluctant to say that it’s parodic (or that the show is a comedy).  Parody, after all makes fun of something and I’m not quite sure what specifically (if anything) is getting made fun of.  As for being a comedy, while the episode was kind of funny and very zany and madcap (it felt almost like Vandread with the fast forward button held down), the pace made it almost hard to laugh at times.  It was so madcap that there was never an opportunity to laugh because they were moving so fast that it’s time for something new.  Jun Fukuyama as Leopold (Leopard?) the Gurren Lagann reject (he totally looks like one of the Gunmen) exemplified that.

(On a side note, it’s like an inverse with part of the problem with the comedic timing in Borat.  I saw it in a packed theater and I felt like I missed half the jokes because everyone was laughing so hard and so long that I couldn’t always hear.)

Random notes:

1) I feel like I had no clue what was going on because the whole thing was going so fast.
2) Tee hee, sci-fi-y magical girl sidekick
3) I kinda/sorta got Otome wa DO MY BEST deshou? vibes from the ED
4) I feared the worst with Masakazu Obara doing the designs since he reuses them constantly.  I don’t mean like how Hisayuki Hirai’s all look the same.  I mean how characters like Lena Sayers and Haruka are exactly the same in both My-Hime and IGPX. Whoopsies!
5) Just looking at the credits now, I see My-Hime seiyuu alumni with Aya Endo, Yukari Tamura, Yukana, Yuka Nanri, Naomi Shindo, and Rie Tanaka
6) And on a final note, wasn’t Idolmaster Xenoglossia also kinda supposed to be a spiritual successor to My-Hime? Sorakake and Idolmaster do share the same writer!


Responses

  1. Does this mean there is potential for mecha-cest?

  2. Wait there’s Yukana in this show and I haven’t watched it yet? Blasphemy!

  3. But it’s OK if it’s with you, Imber?

  4. There’s a bit of staff confusion here, methinks. Masakazu Obara was the director of My-HiME (and Sora Kake). The character designer on My-HiME (and the director of S.ifr) was Hirokazu Hisayuki, who isn’t involved in this show (at least not on the senior staff). Also, Lena and Haruka came from the art for the Cyber Formula videogame spin-offs, not IGXP ^^;

  5. Ah, whoops. I just saw them in that MAIHIME artbook.

  6. In regards to the Xenoglossia thing, what Sunrise technically said about it is that it had the same planning staff as HiME, despite the fact that the whole production staff looked entirely different (alas, Sunrises usual Hajime Yatate credit disguises who actually did the planning). To be honest, it never struck me as much more than Sunrise trying to placate game fans worried about them completely reinventing the property by pointing out the fact that ZHiME wasn’t entirely awful. Plus, it was a very similar show in terms of content, if not tone.

    With Sora Kake, I think it’s the heritage of having the same director that Sunrise considers as making it HiMEs spiritual successor, and I think the similar tone undoubtedly owes itself to that. As important as the writer is in a lot of these things, I do think an anime shows director tends to have a far bigger sway on the outcome of a show than the Western equivalent – Shinbo probably goes without questioning, but how many people realised that Macross Frontier was actually written by the author of My-HiME, Hiroyuki Yoshino, thanks to him playing second fiddle to Kawamori being nuts? It’s not entirely obvious…

    It doesn’t really help that what’s considered a Director in anime terms tends to have an awful lot of overlap with what we’d normally consider a producers job in western terms.

    As for the tone, I’d probably have called HiME franchise farcical rather than parody, particularly the original series which had such a heavy focus on repeatedly building certain expectations only to either ignore them completely or go completely off-tangent to what was epxected.

    (Side note – I found it oddly amusing that the interview mentioned in the link to Hontouni is actually with SoraKakes writer).

    (Side note 2 – I actually have that MAIHIME artbook. It’s nice).

  7. I second the whole writer thing with what DiGiKerot is saying. The couple con panels involving anime writers/scripters that I’ve attended seem to confirm that most of the time, a group of writers are contracted for a particular series to draft the script based on some outline or original work, and doesn’t have all that much creative liberty towards the overall planning of the story.

    This is very much case-by-case, as sometimes the creator do work closely with writers and vice versa, and the amount of liberty given to writers vary between projects. Sometimes one writer writes the entire thing, or almost all of it.

    Perhaps more often than not the whole Hajime Yatate concept might be the most accurate in some of these Sunrise productions, being a truly collaborative work. And this is not so much in terms of writing, but direction.

  8. I first read the title really quickly and was like “WHAT? A series version of the Toki wa Kakeru Shoujo movie?!” XD but then was dissapointed to see it was just some boring anime based on a million others.

  9. It is a spiritual successor. And you can even draw plot connections. It can’t be before HiME, though, so it is set couple of hundred years years in the future, but definately before Otome. Don’t believe me? Why is it Leonard looks so suspiciously like Obsidian lord from HiME?

  10. Fallout is a spiritual successor to Wasteland.

    i remember being a call centre temp as a teenager late 90’s and playing wasteland off a floppy disk whilst getting flamed over the phone. great stuff!

    anyhow like my hime, disliked my otome for its electra complex and had enough of souped up teen nano-lesbos so i’ll pass!

  11. I think if you watch the first episode a few times more, you’ll pick up some new detail each time. Not that it always equates to a good show overall, but the correlation is pretty high.

    In any case, I don’t think it’s a parody or making fun of something in other respects. It felt like to me there was far too much polish/attention to detail on this first episode for it to be not taking itself seriously as a comedy/magical girl/space show. (Well, whatever that means.)

  12. I thought that it was kind of like the tone that something like Nadesico shot for where you know they’re not making fun but still kind of having fun? If that makes any kind of sense?

  13. I didn’t get too overwhelmed by the pacing watching the sub, though I was pre-coffee for the first (boring) half of the first episode.

    I think it has some potential as a comical space adventure (I actually thought Leopard was somewhat amusing), but Sunrise is bad with potential. Basically I wish GAINAX were making this show.


Leave a response

Your response:

Categories